A critical look at Logo by Mike Blamires
Times Educational Supplement October 1987
Overheard in a LOGO classroom.
“She may have made only a square and she really wanted to draw a train but look at the thinking that went into, it, We decided to call it a carriage in the end.”
s the computer language Logo really achieving what its advocates claim it can do? Is a backlash against it about to occur? It seems that at gatherings of teachers who use micros, brownie points may be gained by dismissing Logo.
It might be that it is a victim of fashion. Desk-top publishing and spreadsheets are in vogue while Logo is out. It might be that it has suffered from too much hype over the past couple of years, with the result that many teachers think Logo is about “drawing abstract shapes with a turtle and they can “think of better ways for kids to create patterns, with or without a computer”.
Logo advocates would point out very strongly that Logo is not just about turtle graphics. It is a computer language designed to help children unleash the power of the micro.
In Mindstorms Seymour Papert out-lined the Logo philosophy where the child is an active learner who creates and manipulates knowledge through the medium of Logo. However, while the vast majority of teachers mislu. share Papert’s view of the child, they have not in the main chosen to use Logo or even cut-price cut-down ver sions such as Dart.
Why is Logo failing to thrive? In his book about evolution, The Selfish Gene, Richard Dawkins proposed that ideas operate a bit like genes and coins the term “memes”. Memes are ideas and the principle “survival of the fittest” applies to them. An example of an evil meme would be Nazism, which had an ideal environment for its propagation in the minds of people in the Germany of the Thirties.
Proponents of Logo could say that the classroom environment is far too harsh. In-service training is needed to make it more hospitable. There have been numerous Logo projects around the country over the past few years but they have failed to make inroads into general classroom usage. Logo advo-cates may attribute this to the fact that there was not a full version of Logo available on BBC machines until two years ago.
But two years is a long time in educational computing. Most educational software is seized upon quickly if it is thought to be any good at all. So why is the take up time on Logo so long?
Computer languages, whether cre-ated for children or adults, can be assessed in terms of their range of application and their optimum focus of application. Logo is best at carrying out lists of commands in sequence. It does this to best effect in turtle graphics where the commands FOR-WARD, BACKWARD, LEFT and RIGHT are used to tell a turtle how to draw shapes. The he turtle might be an arrow on the screen or a robot on the floor with a pen.
The commands can be used to build new commands and form the basis for an exploration of geometry. Thus Logo has the desirable feature of programming languages in that it encourages a structured approach which is described as “top-down”.
The usual example given is the drawing of a house. First, the learner Creates the command HOUSE, which consists of the commands TRIANGLE-rand SQUARE. These two com-mands have also to be defined in turn, using the existing commands for mov-ing the turtle. It is significant that the command HOUSE cannot be called HOME, because that is already a Logo command but one with a totally different function.
The structural features of Logo provide a rich world for exploration. Some learners have produced impres-sive spirograph-like patterns and have learned a lot in the process but many others have failed to achieve this. They may be too young, too average, have learning difficulties or be unable to cope with the computer keyboard. However, at least a part of Logo can be made accessible to these childrens when it is modified.
One example is turtle concepts which makes use of the concept keyboard to introduce turtle graphics. The concept keyboard consists of an array of touch-sensitive switches which can be grouped and allocated Logo commands. On to this a paper overlay can be placed, which may have picture prompts instead of words.
are But turtle concepts let learners use only a small part of Logo. They denied the real power of the machine because Logo is text-based and re-quires ideas to be organized in a coded sequence. Logo is letting them down. Programmers need to organize their programs in a top-down and sequential structure in order to work out what went wrong when errors occur in their program. As thinkers who can interpret the world in different ways, we have to represent knowledge many different ways. We may write a list but we are more likely to draw a picture or a diagram. in the old proverb “a picture is worth a thousand words” is at the heart of software developed for the new power-ful machines. If you want to do something with one of these machines, you just point at the picture representing that function and it happens. There is no need to be a programmer to il control the computer and there is no need to accept a programmer’s constraints for representing knowledge: We might want to build models which are relational or multi-layered or which can be radically restructured in an instant and the machines have the potential to let us do it.
In comparison Logo is an unwieldy. dinosaur which has failed to keep up with the advances in technology and knowledge of how we can best interact with a machine. Advocates’ make a virtue out of its necessity for coding, and defend the learner’s frequent lack of results by an appeal to the distortion-tion between content and process. The quote at the beginning of this article illustrates the point..
As teachers, can we defend giving kids tasks that are unnecessarily difficult? There is no reason why a child can’t produce the results he or she wants and still have learned something as well. It is just a question of using the appropriate tools for the job. We do not have to abandon the idea of a child as an active learner constructing know. ledge if we abandon Logo.
In defending Logo uncritically, some advocates are turning their philosophy into a religion whose central tenet might be “Thou shalt have no other tools than Logo”. Perhaps in order for the philosophy of Logo to flourish we should disregard the computer language and start demanding ‘meme machines” which really ‘do let children represent and communicate ideas.
