This Times Educational Supplement article by Carolyn O’Grady from the mid eighties documents some of the early work using overlay or concept keyboards to give learners control over the turtle robot. The article is from the 80s so a little bit of the language of disability and difference is “of its time” but the language changed over time as we learned more about rights and doing things with rather than to learners.
“Special needs is the area where the benefits of microelectronics can most clearly be seen and measured. In this area the computer enables children to do things which they could not do in any other way: it unlocks doors. Children who could not communicate at all or who had no control over their lives can, with the aid of a computer and linked devices, express ideas and advance in learning to a marked degree.
With severely handicapped children, the key to these doors is often the operation of a simple switch. Given the ingenuity of electronics, the mere flicker of an eyelid or a movement of the chin can be enough to open up a new world. Pictures and words on a computer screen have already been made accessible, but there are now other devices apart from the screen which can be micro electronically operated. It is in this area of alternatives to the computer screen that a lot of vigorous research has begun in the four regional Special Education MicroElectronic Resource Centres (SEMERCS) and elsewhere,
Redbridge SEMERC in Ilford, which is responsible for advising over 600 special and mainstream schools on the use of microelectronics in the vast area east and south of Buckingham, taking in London on the way, has taken a particular interest in the possibilities of using robots and turtles linked to the computer, Recently they acquired four Valiant turtles from Valiant Ltd and have lent them out to schools as part of a research project.
Turtle shaped, turtle sized robots, the Valiant turtles can be “taught” to obey a series of commands beginning with, for example, “go forward”, “go backward” or “turn round”. They can also hold a pen which means they can draw a picture as they go.
At Lakeside School in Welwyn Garden City, Vanessa Lees, a teacher, and Tina Detheridge, who holds an advisory job in schools for children with severe learning difficulties in Hertfordshire, have been using one of the turtles with a group of children. The group all have severe learning difficulties, as well as physical handicaps, but there is a wide spread of ability.
On the day I visited the school, the children at Lakeside were operating the turtle by means of buttons or switches which they pressed. For one task the turtle was placed in a centre of a circle of objects including a toy duck and other rubber toys. The children chose an object and the member of the group operating the turtle had to move it round to that object. The task was a lesson in directionality.
Later, the children each took a step _along a piece of paper on the floor and then tried to estimate how many “turtle units” their step measured. When they had done this, one child would get the turtle to measure out unit by unit the length of the step.
In the course of the exercise, Jenny, a very reserved girl who hardly talked at all, developed the ability to count up to 12. At first she couldn’t phase her counting with the switch-pressing which operated the turtle, but with practice she had also learnt to do this. Her self esteem had increased and “the other children had come to see her in a different light”, Vanessa said. “When the turtle comes out she gets very excited.”
Chris, who was the most able of the group, could usually estimate the correct number of turtle units and was able to base his estimate on what had been discovered about the length of previous steps which were pencilled in on the sheet of paper. He could also see whether a small or large turn was required in the directionality task.
We have been surprised at how much learning has taken place,” Tina Detheridge said.
Mike Blamires, who has been working on alternatives to screens at Red-bridge SEMERC, is also convinced that robots and other input and output devices to computers can enhance learning to a considerable degree and in ways which other devices and methods cannot, but he is not convinced that the output device needs to be an expensive turtle (Valiant turtles cost between £270 and £300).
Instead he has adapted very ordinary battery-powered toys furry bunnies, tanks and others including a winsome bear on skates, costing be-tween £10 and £40-into objects that can be activated by the computer. It may not be possible to make these toys do the “high brow” activities which Logo-operated turtles can, he says, but these activities are rarely needed in special education and children often find a furry animal much more exciting.
“These devices”, says Blamires, “are great things for getting kids to co-operate and to talk about. Linked to a computer they offer the children a chance to manipulate objects in the real world.”
A number of computer programs to operate turtles and other devices have been made available through the Special Needs Software Centre’s Blue File system, which makes good quality, freely-copiable software available to special schools or mainstream schools with special needs children. These include Trundle, which allows the kids to use a joystick to guide the toy around and Come and Go, which enables the children to activate the object using their voice. This program has been used as a means of encouraging pupils to say words which they find difficult. Each time they manage to make a sound they are rewarded with a movement of the turtle or furry friend.
The other program, Bridge, is used at Lakeside School. It enables the pupils to control their turtle by means of four switches. These switches don’t necessarily have to be pushed with the hand, they can also be attached to a helmet on the head of, for example, a severe paraplegic, who can then activate the object with a movement. Mike Blamires has also investigated
the use of robotics kits with special needs children. These are the sort of kits manufactured by Lego, Fisher Price or Milton Bradley, which can be made into a number of shapes: to look like, for example an animal or forklift truck and then operated using a motor or through a computer. Using these kits children in mainstream schools, with or without learning difficulties, can build machines and then watch them come alive, but they can also be used to great effect with children with physical disabilities or severe learning difficulties.
One fruitful way of doing this is to link the robot to the very popular program for infants children called Pod. “Pod” is a rotund cartoon man who can do about 50 actions. Children can find out just what he can do by finishing the “Pod can…” sentence which appears on the screen. Using a special interface it is now possible to link the program Pod to a robot which can then be activated in ways similar to the figure on the screen.
Robots linked to the more sophisticated Logo are also proving very motivating with children with mild learning difficulties. Children are fascinated by the ability to make a robot move as they want and in doing so learn a great deal about language and numbers and, if they are doing the task in a group, about interacting with others.
The computer screen and input devices such as the concept keyboard which make it possible for children with learning difficulties to gain access to the computer are already proving their worth. It looks now as though the next device to enlarge the world of the handicapped may well be the robot. “
